'A Youtube for ideas',
BigThink features interviews with savvy intellectuals and artists - quick sound bites on subjects ranging from politics to religion. The site was dreamed up by Peter Hopkins, a 2004 Harvard grad as a place 'to sit down for a few minutes and listen to people who know more than you do'.
Browsing the site, it's clear that BigThink's team has pulled together an impressive list of names. Perhaps
more impressive- these big names came to an office closet to do interviews in front of a shower curtain (see the nytimes feature article below).
Despite the interesting content, I can't help but wonder if the site's philosophy may, in fact, be an internal contradiction. Highly opinionated, college educated, 'intellectual' twenty somethings sit down to get some wisdom from established 'experts'? Well, yes I'm sure a bit of that will happen. But these readers may do more commenting than listening. (Consider the page long comment/monologue posted in response to John McCain's video on the two party system)
While current twenty somethings may be educated and intellectually hungry, we're skeptical of 'big names' (even ivy league educations) and don't expect middle age men in suits to deliver radical, new ideas to shake us to our intellectual core. Twenty somethings are ... well, a generation of super empowered kids.
So, maybe BigThink will migrate towards younger, 'genuine' voices to service young intellectuals. I, for one, liked an interview with Dalia Mogahed, Gallup's Executive Director of Muslim Studies. Or perhaps BigThink will begin to feature readers' comments as center-stage attractions themselves.
Either way, I think a site like this can't survive as simply a window into the minds of smarter, older people. To win over younger users, the exchange of wisdom has to be a two way street.
Visit
http://www.bigthink.com/ to see for yourself.
Or read the New York Times article first:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/07/technology/07summers.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&ref=media
The interview with Dalia Mogahed :
http://www.bigthink.com/identity/876